November 21, 2018 Community news from the prairie to the lakes  
Home News Sports Obituaries Opinion Classifieds
  Rural influence could be waning
  BY REED ANFINSON, Publisher, Grant County Herald

There was a time when many may have thought of Grant County as primarily Democratic. One of the blue rural western counties along with Big Stone and Swift. In recent history, it has often voted for both Republicans and Democrats. But that may be changing, as like much of rural Minnesota, it turns more solidly Republican red.

In the 2018 election, Grant County voted for Democrats Sen. Amy Klobuchar and 7th District U.S. Rep. Collin Peterson. However, it voted for Republicans Jeff Johnson for governor by a wide margin, and U.S. Senate candidate Karen Housley over Democratic Sen. Tina Smith. It also returned Rep. Backer to the state House. The candidates who won election for the state executive positions of attorney general, secretary of state and auditor were all Republican.

Based on the Nov. 6 elections, Grant County, along with much of rural Minnesota, is becoming more conservative. Even the once Democratic stronghold of the 8th Congressional District in northeast Minnesota has become Republican. Unless the Democrats run a candidate with broad personal appeal to voters, such as Peterson or Klobuchar, they are going to cast their ballot for a Republican.

And, based on the changing demographics in the state, that does not bode well for rural Minnesota’s influence in state government.

Why is rural Minnesota turning predominantly Republican? Its voters are older, mostly white, and more socially conservative than voters in metropolitan areas of the state. They see Democrats as the party that gives handouts to undeserving people who are living off the system and their hard work.

They are rigid in their stands about welcoming immigrants who didn’t come here through the proper channels. However, this may also be a cover for some not wanting immigrants of other colors, religions, and social norms than we have in rural Minnesota. Republicans, primarily Trump, have done a thorough job of creating fear of immigrants, saying they bring violent crime with them.

Since the passage of the Affordable Care Act in March 2010, Republicans have blamed Democrats for rising healthcare costs. That is changing, however, as Republicans have moved to end the ACA, taking health insurance coverage away from many who previously couldn’t afford it.

What we saw from this recent election is the likely future of Minnesota politics: Rural Minnesota becoming ever more Republican and the metropolitan areas solidly in the Democrats’ camp. The bad news for Republicans is that the Twin Cities metropolitan area is growing rapidly with the seven-county metropolitan area already representing 57 percent of the state’s population.

A look at the state’s governor’s race shows just how skewed vote totals, and electability, are toward Democrats in the Twin Cities area.

Governor-elect Tim Walz won the race for governor getting 1,392,348 votes – with 899,942 of those votes coming from the seven-county metropolitan area. Walz beat Hennepin County Commissioner and Republican candidate Johnson by 372,396 votes in those seven counties.

The four rural Minnesota congressional districts that encompass nearly all of Minnesota except the metropolitan area, the 1st, 2nd, 7th and 8th, favored Johnson giving him 609,749 votes to Walz’s 572,326 – but that provided him a margin of only 37,423 votes.

Just three counties – Ramsey, Hennepin, and Dakota gave Walz 704,395 votes to Johnson’s 333,024 – Walz won the three by 371,371 votes; that is a staggering vote total to overcome in the other 84 counties of the state.

The Nov. 6 election represented the 12th consecutive year that Republicans have not won a statewide election for the governor’s office or the U.S. Senate, showing the growing weight of Minneapolis and St. Paul, and the suburbs around them in deciding elections. They also haven’t won the secretary of state, auditor or attorney general’s office since 2006.

It was the suburbs of the Twin Cities that were primarily responsible for the DFL regaining control of the state House by picking up 18 seats, far more than the 11 it needed to again be in the majority. With its return to power led by suburban votes, it is no surprise that the new leadership starting in January will also be suburban.

Representative Melissa Hortman of Brooklyn Park is likely to become the next speaker of the House, with Ryan Winkler of Golden Valley the new majority leader. Representative Liz Olson of Duluth is slated to become the next House majority whip. These leadership positions set the agenda for House legislation.

If the metropolitan area goes blue with increasing frequency and rural Minnesota turns ever more red, the demographics of the state will relegate us to minority party status in the Legislature. What that means is that our Republican representatives in the House will become a smaller voice for rural issues. They will get no committee chairmanships, and their ability to shepherd bills into law will be weakened. Metropolitan legislators will decide rural issues.

Further, we may see the DFL Party write off of rural Minnesota as they focus their campaigns where the votes are. What is Grant County with its 1,287 DFL votes compared to the seven-county metro with its nearly 900,000 votes for Walz?

Minnesota’s new governor has rural roots. He grew up a small town in northwest Nebraska, graduating from Butte High School with a class of 25. He became a geography teacher and coach at Mankato West High School and served six terms in the U.S. House representing southern Minnesota. He knows rural issues and cares about rural communities. As governor, we hope Walz keeps rural issues in front of a growing metropolitan-based Legislature.



  Back to top
  Thanks for reading the Grant County Herald website. For complete news stories, opinion pieces, sports, arts and entertainment, lots of photographs, obituaries, and more, please check the full print or full online version of the Grant County Herald. To subscribe to the Herald print version, contact Penny at To subscribe to the full online version, please click here and follow instructions. Thank you—we appreciate your readership!
Classifieds Ads
Display Ads
Elbow Lake Police Department
Grant County Website
Grant County Financial Statement
Thorson Library
West Central Area Schools
Extension Office
Grant County Humane Society
City of Ashby
City of Barrett
City of Elbow Lake/Chamber
City of Herman
City of Wendell
Lakeland Mental Health Center
Central Lakes Trail
(Un)Cannery Row Blog
Sign up for the free Savvy Senior e-mail newsletter
Loading Family Features Content Widget

Website last updated:
November 20, 2018